Friday Fish Fry · Madison
Toby's Supper Club
Family-owned southeast-side supper club established in 1944 whose Friday fish fry includes cod, perch and catfish.
3717 S Dutch Mill Rd, Madison, WI 53718
What we checked
- Fish fry
- Served on Fridays. Fish: cod, perch, catfish, bluegill. Sides: coleslaw, rye bread, baked potato, french fries, relish tray, cinnamon rolls.
- Supper club
- Calls itself a supper club, or is widely known as one.
- Founded
- 1944 (the year checked against the place's own history page or local news)
- Honors
- Listed on Ron Faiola's Wisconsin Supper Clubs List (wisconsinsupperclubs.com, 2026)
- Listed in Travel Wisconsin's supper club guide (travelwisconsin.com/food-drink/supper-clubs, accessed 2026)
- Featured in National Geographic's 'To truly experience Wisconsin, head to the supper club' (April 2026)
- Featured in Ron Faiola's documentary 'We're Here for a Fish Fry!' (2017)
- Kind of place
- Supper Club
Checked open in September 2026 against a 2025 or 2026 source: the place's own site or menu, local news, or its Travel Wisconsin listing. Days and menus change, so check with Toby's Supper Club before you go. Hours, photos and ratings are Apple Maps' own, in its place card. Something wrong? Tell us.
Nearby on our lists
- Tully's II Food and SpiritsMonona · 1.2 mi · fish fry
- Green Lantern RestaurantMcFarland · 1.3 mi · supper club and fish fry
- Angelo'sMcFarland · 2.1 mi · fish fry
- Maple Tree Supper ClubMcFarland · 2.2 mi · supper club and fish fry
- Christy's LandingMadison · 3.1 mi · fish fry
- Michael's Frozen CustardMadison · 3.1 mi · custard
More: Wisconsin fish fry guide · Wisconsin supper clubs · Madison page
Save it for Friday
The free Wisconsin Eats app has Toby's Supper Club and 16,345 other Wisconsin places, sorted by distance from you, with Apple Maps' live hours and photos.
Get early accessFree for iPhone and iPad. Coming to the App Store.