Wisconsin Eats · Sheboygan, WisconsinSheboygan fish fries, supper clubs & restaurants
3 Friday fish fries, 9 supper clubs and 0 custard stands in and around Sheboygan, each checked open in September 2026. The Wisconsin Eats app has all 195 restaurants, cafés, taverns and bakeries in Sheboygan and sorts them by distance from you.
Friday fish fry in and near Sheboygan
Places in Sheboygan first, then others within 12 miles, closest first. Fish and days as each place lists them. All 395 Wisconsin fish fries.
Downtown 925
925 N 8th St, Sheboygan
Supper clubFish fry Fish: cod, perch · Fish fry: Friday · Sides: fries, rye bread, coleslaw
Former Rupp's Downtown supper club, renamed Downtown 925 by new owners in 2025, serving dinner Thursday through Sunday with a Friday fish fry of beer-battered cod or hand-breaded perch.
Majerle's Black River Grill
5033 Evergreen Dr, Sheboygan
Supper clubFish fry Fish: bluegill · Fish fry: Wednesday, Friday · Sides: fries, coleslaw, rye bread
Sheboygan grill with a Friday fish fry plate and Wednesday all-you-can-eat bluegill, open Wednesday through Sunday.
The Horse & Plow
419 Highland Dr, Kohler · 3 mi from Sheboygan
Fish fry Fish: perch · Fish fry: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday · Sides: coleslaw, rye bread, fries · Since 1924
Pub at The American Club in Kohler, a village gathering place since 1924, with a half-pound lake perch fish fry on its daily menu.
Supper clubs near Sheboygan
Supper clubs in Sheboygan, then others within 25 miles, closest first. All 209 Wisconsin supper clubs.
Downtown 925
925 N 8th St, Sheboygan
Supper clubFish fry Fish: cod, perch · Fish fry: Friday · Sides: fries, rye bread, coleslaw
Former Rupp's Downtown supper club, renamed Downtown 925 by new owners in 2025, serving dinner Thursday through Sunday with a Friday fish fry of beer-battered cod or hand-breaded perch.
Majerle's Black River Grill
5033 Evergreen Dr, Sheboygan
Supper clubFish fry Fish: bluegill · Fish fry: Wednesday, Friday · Sides: fries, coleslaw, rye bread
Sheboygan grill with a Friday fish fry plate and Wednesday all-you-can-eat bluegill, open Wednesday through Sunday.
Rupp's Supperclub
1102 W Washington Ave, Cleveland · 11 mi from Sheboygan
Supper club
Manitowoc County supper club, taken over by longtime Rupp family employee Tera Castillo in 2023, known for aging and cutting its own steaks.
Chissy's Pub & Grill
215 WI-28, Waldo · 12 mi from Sheboygan
Supper club
Supper club in the village of Waldo serving old fashioneds, prime rib and Sunday brunch.
PJ Campbells at The Depot
114 Depot Rd, Plymouth · 13 mi from Sheboygan
Supper clubFish fry Fish: perch, cod, catfish · Fish fry: Friday
German-American restaurant in Plymouth's 1912 railroad depot with Friday fish specials and Saturday prime rib.
Millhome Supper Club
16524 Lax Chapel Rd, Kiel · 16 mi from Sheboygan
Supper clubFish fry Fish: perch, walleye, haddock · Fish fry: Friday · Sides: mashed potatoes, potato wedges, french fries, hash browns, baked potato
Countryside supper club near Kiel with a Friday fish fry of breaded lake perch, beer-battered walleye or beer-battered haddock, Saturday prime rib and Sunday brunch.
Schwarz's Supper Club
W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein · 22 mi from Sheboygan
Supper clubFish fry Fish: perch · Fish fry: Friday · Since 1957
Family-run supper club in the hamlet of St. Anna that Ziggy and Evelyn Schwarz started as a country tavern in 1957, serving steaks, seafood and a Friday night perch fry.
Green Street Food & Spirits
1801 S 10th St, Manitowoc · 23 mi from Sheboygan
Supper club
Manitowoc restaurant with small-town supper club style, on Ron Faiola's supper club list, serving lake perch and rainbow trout dinners.
Altona Supper Club
2306 Calumet Dr, New Holstein · 24 mi from Sheboygan
Supper clubFish fry Fish: ocean perch, catfish, redfish, haddock, tilapia · Fish fry: Friday · Sides: mashed potatoes, clam chowder, salad bar · Since 1937
New Holstein supper club opened in 1937 that runs a Friday seafood buffet with battered and baked fish alongside soup and salad bar.
Sheboygan icons
James Beard Award winners, finalists and semifinalists, and long-running local institutions, most honored first. Honors are from the James Beard Foundation's own award records and other named sources.
City Bakery
1102 Michigan Ave, Sheboygan
Since 1939
Sheboygan bakery open since 1939 that bakes Sheboygan hard rolls in a brick hearth oven using a sponge-and-dough method.
Johnston's Bakery
1227 Superior Ave, Sheboygan
Since 1950
Family-owned Sheboygan bakery, founded in 1950 and on Superior Ave since 1957, that calls itself the 'Home of the Sheboygan Hard Roll' and also runs a frozen-dough plant.
Schulz's Restaurant
1644 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan
Since 1953
Family-run Sheboygan restaurant since 1953 that serves charcoal-grilled brats and steak sandwiches on hard rolls, using meat from Miesfeld's.
Oldest restaurants in Sheboygan
Founding years checked against the restaurant's own history page or local news, oldest first.
City Bakery
1102 Michigan Ave, Sheboygan
Since 1939
Sheboygan bakery open since 1939 that bakes Sheboygan hard rolls in a brick hearth oven using a sponge-and-dough method.
Johnston's Bakery
1227 Superior Ave, Sheboygan
Since 1950
Family-owned Sheboygan bakery, founded in 1950 and on Superior Ave since 1957, that calls itself the 'Home of the Sheboygan Hard Roll' and also runs a frozen-dough plant.
Schulz's Restaurant
1644 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan
Since 1953
Family-run Sheboygan restaurant since 1953 that serves charcoal-grilled brats and steak sandwiches on hard rolls, using meat from Miesfeld's.
What Sheboygan eats
The most common kinds of restaurant among the 195 in Sheboygan, from open map data and the city and county license lists.
| Kind of place | Places |
|---|---|
| Bar & Pub | 71 |
| Coffee & Café | 17 |
| Mexican | 16 |
| Pizza | 16 |
| Burgers | 13 |
| Bakery & Sweets | 11 |
| Sandwiches & Deli | 9 |
| American & Other | 8 |
| Italian | 5 |
| Breakfast & Diner | 5 |